# The rhetoric in mathematics: Newton, Leibniz, the calculus, and the rhetorical force of the infinitesimal

@article{Reyes2004TheRI, title={The rhetoric in mathematics: Newton, Leibniz, the calculus, and the rhetorical force of the infinitesimal}, author={Mitchell G. Reyes}, journal={Quarterly Journal of Speech}, year={2004}, volume={90}, pages={163 - 188} }

This essay investigates the rhetoric surrounding the appearance of the concept of the infinitesimal in the seventeenth‐century Calculus of Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. Although historians often have positioned rhetoric as a supplemental discipline, this essay shows that rhetoric is the “material” out of which a new and powerful mathematical system emerges. At the height of empiricism, the infinitesimal, thought by Newton and Leibniz to be evanescent or nascent, made available… Expand

#### 20 Citations

Theorizing Chemical Rhetoric: Toward an Articulation of Chemistry as a Public Vocabulary

- 2021

Chemistry has been a pivotal part of scientific discovery and human life for centuries. This essay argues that chemical terms, tropes, figures, appeals, and narratives serve as powerful rhetorical… Expand

Number, Newtonianism, and Sublimity in James Thomson's The Seasons

- History
- 2010

Number, Newtonianism, and Sublimity in James Thomson’s The Seasons Jessie Leatham Wirkus Department of English Master of Arts Recently, literary critics have increasingly drawn on methods of… Expand

A Burgessian Critique of Nominalistic Tendencies in Contemporary Mathematics and its Historiography

- Philosophy, Mathematics
- 2012

We analyze the developments in mathematical rigor from the viewpoint of a Burgessian critique of nominalistic reconstructions. We apply such a critique to the reconstruction of infinitesimal analysis… Expand

Machinic rhetorics and the influential movements of robots

- Sociology
- 2018

ABSTRACT From spiritual vehicles, channeling the miracle of Christ, to science incarnate, operating beyond human interest, machines can communicate. Building from literatures on posthuman performance… Expand

Forms Visualizing Communication: Notes Regarding the Parallels of Argumentation between Rhetoric and Geometry as Basic Communication Tools

- Computer Science
- 2008

It is argued that not only terminological, but also structural similarities between graphic, mathematical, and rhetorical communication exist and exemplify this claim by discussion examples from these fields. Expand

Calculating the Weather: Deductive Reasoning and Disciplinary Telos in Cleveland Abbe's Rhetorical Transformation of Meteorology

- Sociology
- 2011

This paper explores the rhetorical basis of a major paradigm change in meteorology, from a focus on inductive observation to deductive, mathematical reasoning. Analysis of Cleveland Abbe's “The… Expand

The Continuity Postulate in Economic Theory: A Deconstruction and an Integration

- Economics, Mathematics
- 2021

This paper presents six theorems and ten propositions that can be read as deconstructing and integrating the continuity postulate under the rubric of pioneering work of Eilenberg, Wold, von… Expand

Articulating Scientific Practice: Understanding Dean Hamer's “Gay Gene” Study as Overlapping Material, Social and Rhetorical Registers

- Sociology
- 2009

Rhetoricians have tried to develop a better understanding of the connection between words and things, but these attempts often employ a logic of representation that undermines a full examination of… Expand

Infinitesimal Time Scale Calculus

- Mathematics
- 2011

Calculus has historically been fragmented into multiple distinct theories such as differential calculus, difference calculus, quantum calculus, and many others. These theories are all about the… Expand

Capstones 1-1-2011 Infinitesimal Time Scale Calculus

- 2013

Calculus has historically been fragmented into multiple distinct theories such as differential calculus, difference calculus, quantum calculus, and many others. These theories are all about the… Expand

#### References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 58 REFERENCES

Science as a Rhetorical Transaction: Toward a Nonjustificational Conception of Rhetoric

- 2005

This essay reconceptualizes rhetoric, logic, and dialectic within a nonjustificational metatheoretical framework. It argues that science, in its various functions as a mode of inquiry into and… Expand

Rhetoric of Science without Constraints

- Sociology
- 1991

In 1979, Bruno Latour and Steve Woolgar crossed the invisible line that divided the social from the scientific, opinion from knowledge. The subtitle of Laboratory Life: The Social Construction of… Expand

Review essay: The rhetorical turn in science studies

- Philosophy
- 1996

A RHETORIC OF SCIENCE: INVENTING SCIENTIFIC DISCOURSE. By Lawrence Prelli. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1989; xi + pp. 321. $34.95. NOVELTIES IN THE HEAVENS; RHETORIC AND SCIENCE IN… Expand

Physics and language-science and rhetoric : Reviewing the parallel evolution of theory on motion and meaning in the aftermath of the Sokal hoax

- Philosophy
- 1999

Alan Sokal's concern about a decline in intellectual standards includes an indictment of what he calls current “subjectivist” trends accompanying a general erosion of “objectivity “ stemming from… Expand

The rhetorical understanding of science: An explication and critical commentary

- Philosophy
- 1987

Inspired by the Weltanschauungen opposition to positivist philosophy of science and the current interest in the relation of rhetoric and knowledge, some writers in rhetorical theory have argued that… Expand

A masterpiece in a new genre: The rhetorical negotiation of two audiences in schrödinger's “what is life?”

- Sociology
- 1994

Critics may fail to appreciate the rhetorical significance of scientific texts that do not fit within the dominant genre of truth‐forming argument. Only by identifying Schrodinger's text as… Expand

The Metaphysical Foundations of Modern Physical Science: a Historical and Critical Essay.

- Nature
- 1925

PROF. BURTT has given us a study of the history of modern science from an unusual but very important point of view. He has sought to lay bare the principle underlying and directing scientific… Expand

Forms of Knowledge in Mathematics and Mathematics Education: Philosophical and Rhetorical Perspectives

- 1999

New forms of mathematical knowledge are growing in importance for mathematics and education, including tacit knowledge; knowledge of particulars, language and rhetoric in mathematics. These… Expand

Rhetoric of Science.

- Philosophy
- 1991

Before we begin, please take another look at the title; in particular, please notice that, open-ended and swollen though it is, it manages to avoid three words, one big, one mid-sized, and, in the… Expand

Words and Numbers: Mathematical Dimensions of Rhetoric.

- Sociology
- 1990

This essay investigates how numbers function rhetorically by influencing persuasive appeals, the structure of messages, and our use of language. The author argues that “three” is the dominant… Expand